One of the most common questions I get from people moving to North Idaho is: Should I live in Sandpoint or Sagle Idaho? Since I’ve lived in both areas, I can give you an honest breakdown of what life is really like in each town. Depending on your lifestyle, preferences, and daily routine, this could be a bigger decision than you think. So let’s dive into the key differences between these two communities and, at the end, I’ll reveal which one I prefer!
1. Population & Density
Starting with Sagle, it’s tough to pin down an exact population number because it’s such a vast area. Divided by Highway 95, Sagle consists of large parcels of land—ranging from 5 to 40+ acres. However, there are also higher-density areas like Bottle Bay, Wooded Acres, Comeback Bay, and the Crystal Loop Gun Club area, especially near the waterfront.
In Sandpoint, about 13,000 people live in the downtown area, but when you zoom out, you’ll find large parcels of land and plenty of space. While Sandpoint has more concentrated areas of housing, both locations offer a mix of high-density living and wide-open spaces. Verdict: A Draw.
YouTube Video – click to watch
2. Local Government & Regulations
Sagle is unincorporated, meaning there’s no local government, and law enforcement is handled by the Bonner County Sheriff’s Office. While taxes may be lower due to limited public services, there’s also less oversight when it comes to building regulations, giving residents more freedom.
Sandpoint, on the other hand, does have a city government. However, compared to other states like Washington or California, its regulations are still relatively relaxed. If you want structure, Sandpoint might be a better fit, but if you prefer fewer rules, Sagle has the edge. Verdict: A Tie (Depends on Preference).
3. Housing Costs
If you think Sagle is more affordable, think again! Here’s a comparison based on a 12-month rolling average for a 3-bed, 2-bath home:
- Sagle: $649,000
- Sandpoint: $635,000
While Sandpoint is slightly less expensive, both areas are in the same price range. Verdict: Sandpoint Wins (Slightly Lower Prices).
4. Amenities
Sagle is mainly residential with a few businesses like a gas station, storage units, Dollar General, and Pierce Auto (great local car dealership). There are no major restaurants or shopping centers, and local events are limited.
Sandpoint, however, offers multiple grocery stores, medical facilities, car washes, parks, bars, and live music venues like The Hive. It also hosts events like Lost in the ‘50s, the Festival at Sandpoint, and holiday parades. Plus, with Schweitzer Mountain Resort nearby, winter recreation is top-notch. Verdict: Sandpoint Wins (More to Do).
5. State Parks
Sagle boasts Round Lake State Park, a fantastic spot for kayaking, paddleboarding, and hiking. It’s also close to Farragut State Park, which offers even more outdoor activities.
Sandpoint, surprisingly, has zero state parks. Verdict: Sagle Wins (Better Access to State Parks).
6. Transportation & Traffic
Neither town has much public transportation. Sandpoint has Spot Bus, which connects to Dover and Schweitzer, but Uber and Lyft are rare, and taxis are limited.
The biggest transportation factor? The Long Bridge. This bridge connects Sandpoint to Sagle, and if there’s an accident, your commute could jump from 5 minutes to over an hour. If you need to cross daily, this could be a deal-breaker. Verdict: Sandpoint Wins (Less Reliance on the Long Bridge).
7. Waterfront Homes & Views
Many assume Sandpoint has the best waterfront homes, but Sagle actually offers more options along Bottle Bay, Garfield Bay, Camp Bay, and the Pend Oreille River. Sandpoint does have waterfront properties, but they’re limited in comparison.
Verdict: Sagle Wins (More Waterfront Options).
8. Snowfall
Sandpoint experiences more snow due to its microclimate, especially in higher elevations. Sagle gets snow too, but typically less. Whether this is a pro or con depends on your preference for winter weather. Verdict: Depends (More Snow vs. Less Snow).
My Personal Preference: Sandpoint
While Sagle offers larger parcels and more waterfront opportunities, my daily life revolves around Sandpoint. With my kids’ activities, work, and local events, I prefer being north of the Long Bridge to avoid potential traffic delays. When I first moved here, the bridge didn’t bother me, but after experiencing disruptions, I appreciate the convenience of living in Sandpoint.
However, if you’re looking for a quieter, more private lifestyle with more space and waterfront options, Sagle could be your ideal choice.
What About You?
Do you prefer Sandpoint or Sagle? Let me know in the comments—I’d love to hear your thoughts!
If you’re considering moving to North Idaho and need help finding the perfect home, let’s connect! Schedule a one-on-one consultation using the link in the description below. I’m here to help you make the right move for your lifestyle and needs!