Sandpoint’s Future: Growth, Controversy, and the Battle Over Development

Ben Geanetta, a Sandpoint, Idaho realtor, reacting to a controversy about the town’s growth. The background features an aerial view of downtown Sandpoint, City Beach, and the Long Bridge. This thumbnail is for a YouTube video discussing Sandpoint’s rapid development and the debate over its future

Sandpoint, Idaho, is at a crossroads. Known for its small-town charm, stunning lake views, and tight-knit community, the town has long been a haven for those seeking a quieter, more natural lifestyle. But as more people discover Sandpoint, new developments are emerging—bringing both excitement and fierce resistance from locals.

From a waterfront luxury hotel to a controversial sports complex, a major mountain bike park, and other large-scale projects, the town is grappling with a big question: How much growth is too much?

Here’s a look at the major developments shaping Sandpoint’s future, the local backlash they’ve sparked, and what it all means for residents, businesses, and potential homebuyers.


1. The Waterfront & Downtown Hotel Projects – A Boost for Tourism or the End of Small-Town Charm?

Two major hotel projects are in the works for Sandpoint: a waterfront luxury hotel with private residences and a downtown hotel by Averill Hospitality.

What’s Happening?

  • The waterfront development will include high-end accommodations and private residential units, catering to luxury buyers.
  • The downtown hotel is being developed by Averill Hospitality, a company known for high-end resorts.
  • Both aim to capitalize on Sandpoint’s growing popularity as a four-season destination.

Why Some Support These Projects:

✔️ Boosts local tourism and economy – More visitors mean more revenue for restaurants, shops, and outdoor recreation businesses.
✔️ Creates jobs – Hospitality and service industries could see an increase in employment opportunities.
✔️ Puts Sandpoint on the map – Competes with other resort towns like Whitefish and Coeur d’Alene, bringing in higher-end travelers.
✔️ Increases property values – More investment in the area could raise real estate prices, benefiting homeowners.

Why Locals Are Pushing Back:

Privatization of waterfront access – Many fear that the lakefront will become less accessible to the public, favoring wealthy residents and visitors.
Increased traffic and parking congestion – More visitors mean more cars, straining Sandpoint’s already limited infrastructure.
Risk of over-commercialization – Some worry Sandpoint is becoming a corporate resort town rather than a small, locally-driven community.
Rising cost of living – Higher property values may sound great for homeowners but could push out locals who can no longer afford to live in their own town.

The Big Question:

Will these hotels enhance Sandpoint’s economy and appeal, or are they the first step toward turning the town into an exclusive resort community?


2. James E. Russell Sports Center – A Win for Youth Sports or an Expensive Misstep?

A new indoor sports complex is under construction, promising year-round facilities for basketball, soccer, and other sports.

Why Some Support It:

✔️ Provides much-needed recreation for local youth.
✔️ Could bring in sports tournaments, boosting the local economy.
✔️ Encourages healthy, active lifestyles in the community.

Why Locals Are Pushing Back:

❌ Concerns over funding—should taxpayers foot the bill?
❌ Traffic and parking issues in the surrounding area.
❌ Some question if it’s the right priority for Sandpoint’s growth.

The Big Question:

Is this facility a great investment in the community or a misplaced mega-project?


3. Panhandle Bike Ranch – Outdoor Paradise or Unwanted Development?

A proposed mountain bike park in Sagle has sparked a fierce debate.

What’s Happening?

  • A large-scale mountain bike park is planned for the Sagle area.
  • Designed to attract mountain bikers from across the region.
  • Some residents welcome the outdoor recreation boost, while others say it threatens Sagle’s quiet, rural lifestyle.

Why Some Support It:

✔️ Creates a new recreation spot for locals and tourists.
✔️ Brings in outdoor enthusiasts, boosting local tourism.
✔️ Could put Sandpoint on the map as a biking destination.

Why Locals Are Pushing Back:

❌ Disrupts the quiet, rural nature of Sagle.
❌ Environmental concerns—wildlife impact and erosion.
❌ Some see it as catering more to tourists than residents.

The Big Question:

Will this project enhance outdoor recreation or permanently alter Sagle’s rural charm?


4. Field of Dreams Recreation Complex – The One Project with Broad Support

Unlike other developments, the Field of Dreams recreation complex in Ponderay has been widely embraced.

Why It’s Different:

✔️ Designed for local families, schools, and community use.
✔️ Minimal disruption to residential neighborhoods.
✔️ Funded through partnerships rather than taxpayer burdens.

The Big Question:

What can other developers learn from Field of Dreams’ success?


What’s Next for Sandpoint?

The tension between preserving Sandpoint’s charm and embracing inevitable growth is only growing. While these projects offer economic benefits, they also challenge what it means to live in Sandpoint.

👉 Is Sandpoint transforming into an elite resort town?
👉 Can growth happen without losing the community’s character?
👉 How will these developments impact real estate and home values?

If you’re considering buying or selling in Sandpoint, now is the time to understand these changes. Let’s talk about how this evolving market could affect you. Reach out today for expert real estate advice!